201: The Cost of Keeping the Wrong High Performer

Culture, Competency, and the Hard Call of Letting Someone Go

Joey Brannon explains why culture and competency are not an either/or, and why a culture miss has to be dealt with by day 60, before the culture pays for it.

The Cost of Keeping the Wrong High Performer
Host: John Staub | The Business & Faith Podcast
 
Grow With Purpose Episode 201 graphic: The Cost of Keeping the Wrong High Performer, with host John Staub and guest Joey Brannon.
 

Host: John Staub, The Business & Faith Podcast® | Guest: Joey Brannon, CEO and Founder, Axiom Strategic

This episode first aired on The Business & Faith Podcast®, hosted by John Staub. Joey Brannon joins John to talk about culture, competency, and the hard calls that come with leading people, including why the onboarding plan should be written before the job is posted. Joey also talks plainly about his faith and about treating indecision as poor stewardship. Add The Business & Faith Podcast to your rotation at businessandfaithpodcast.com.

In This Episode, You’ll Learn

  • Why culture and competency are not an either/or

  • How values, vision, why, and mission define a culture

  • Why the onboarding plan gets written before the job is posted

  • Why you'll know by day 30 and have no excuses by day 60

References and Downloadable Resources

Frequently Asked Questions

Are culture and competency an either/or when you hire?

No. You need both. A salesperson who closes deals but nobody can stand to work with creates a problem for the team. So does someone who lives out the company’s values but can’t close a sale. Your onboarding process needs to measure both culture and competency.

What do the first 60 to 90 days of a hire reveal?

Whether the person can do the job and whether their actions match what they said in the interview about the company’s values and vision. Joey says you’ll know by 30 days and have no excuses by 60.

Why should the onboarding plan be written before the job is posted?

For leadership roles and the management layer below them, decide what you need from the role and plan the first weeks before recruiting. If the role already exists, review what has and hasn’t worked. That gives you a consistent standard before a candidate enters the picture. Joey’s example is a roofing field production manager who spends the first week with a different crew each day, even with 20 years of residential experience.

What does it cost the team when an owner waits too long on a culture miss?

The team pays the price for the friction that person creates, even if they’re getting projects done or making sales. Joey recalls a mentor framing it as a question of stewardship: when everyone, including the owner, agrees someone shouldn’t be there, delaying the change means running the business for that one person’s benefit.

How do values, vision, why, and mission define a culture?

Joey describes four parts:

  • Values: Three or four words with definitions that make clear which behaviors the company will promote and which it won’t tolerate.

  • Vision: An explicit finish line the whole team can see.

  • Why: The reason that vision is worth everyone’s best effort.

  • Mission: What the team completes each day, whether or not they close a deal or finish a project.

With those four in place, culture forms as the team does hard work together.

How does faith shape the decision to let someone go?

Joey says his faith makes the decision easier. He asks whether he believes he is in control of that person’s well-being or whether God is. When it’s clear to everyone that the person shouldn’t be there, he believes God has something else for them or may use the hard decision to speak truth into their life. He recalls someone returning years later to say it was the best thing for them. He views indecision as poor stewardship of wisdom, understanding, and discernment.

Listen to the full episode for more on hiring, onboarding, and protecting your company’s culture.

 
Get Grow With Purpose in your inbox
New episodes and practical tools for business owners, straight to your email.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.
 
Next
Next

200: The Succession Trap - Why 70% of Businesses Can't Transfer Value